This proposal for ages 10 and above uses simple objects without wagers. Its result is a demonstration of two end positions and an explanation of why advice learned for one version cannot automatically be applied to the other.

Two references with two winning conditions

Advertisementpreview

The University of Cambridge NRICH project's Nim-7 page says the player taking the last counter wins. The Nim activity in its KS2 Maths Fair pack instead says that player loses.

These sources allow you to explore two identified variants. Do not mix their instructions or claim one is the only form of Nim. The game's name does not replace reading its rules.

In both versions of this practice, there are two players and one initial group of seven counters. Each turn removes one or two. You cannot pass or return pieces.

Begin near the ending

Set out just one counter. When taking the last wins, whoever has the turn wins by removing it. When taking the last loses, the same action produces the opposite result.

Now try two counters. In the last-wins version, you can take both and win. In the last-loses version, removing one leaves the other for your opponent, who must take it.

This comparison explains why memorizing “always take two” does not solve the problem. Your choice depends on the position and ending condition.

Investigate three counters when the last wins

With three counters under the last-wins rule, removing one leaves two; removing two leaves one. Either way, your opponent can take everything remaining and win.

Against somebody who makes that choice, receiving a turn with three counters is therefore unfavourable. Ask your partner to test both possibilities rather than simply accept the explanation.

Return to seven. The first player can remove one, leaving six. They then aim for each pair of turns to remove three in total: if the opponent takes one, respond with two; if they take two, respond with one. This leaves three and subsequently reaches the last counter.

Read alsoDominica’s Sisserou and Jaco — does endemic mean endangered?

Change the condition and rebuild the reasoning

When taking the last loses, receiving one counter is unfavourable. Receiving four can be unfavourable too: either permitted removal lets your opponent leave just one on the next move.

Advertisementpreview

Test this with four. Taking one leaves three, so the other player takes two. Taking two leaves two, so the other takes one. Both paths leave one counter for the starting player.

With seven, the second player can aim to leave four and then one. If the first takes one, the second takes two; if the first takes two, the second takes one. The pattern preserves an unfavourable position for the opponent. The initial advantage differs from the other variant.

Explain without calling your partner careless

Winning one game does not prove somebody understands the pattern. It may have happened because the opponent made a different choice. To demonstrate reasoning, show what happens for both permitted choices available to the other player.

Alternate who begins and which rule is active. Announce the variant before placing the seven counters. Changing it after somebody takes the last counter is not a new strategy: it retrospectively changes the agreement.

If a pair struggles, return to one, two, three and four counters. Observing small endings helps explain a larger game.

What to present to the unit

Show the three-counter position under last-wins and the four-counter position under last-loses. Demonstrate the possible responses and explain the difference.

The central skill is reading the winning condition before seeking a pattern. It supports club logic games and prevents treating similar rules as identical.

To finish, give another pair one of the rules without announcing who has the initial advantage. They should explain a small ending before using a memorized recommendation about who starts.