Make four observations before explaining the change

Gather a clean polished metal spoon, paper and an upward-pointing arrow drawn on the paper. Work in a well-lit room using ordinary ambient light. One person holds the spoon still. The other places the arrow where it appears clearly, then brings the paper closer slowly while the observer describes the image. Swap jobs so that both Pathfinders can see the change and compare what they noticed.

Advertisementpreview

Give the record sheet four rows. Label the first two “concave side, close” and “concave side, farther away.” Use two more for the convex side. Say whether the arrow looks upright or upside down and whether it appears larger or smaller. Record the distances you actually tried. Keep the results where you could identify the image clearly. A camera image can help illustrate the record when it captures what you saw. Exploratorium, mirror activities.

How the curve changes reflected light

Reflected light reaches your eyes along paths that depend on the object position and the surface. The Exploratorium's geometry activities show how viewing changes when the reflecting surface curves. On the concave side, changing the object's distance can bring you through a region where the image changes orientation. On the convex side, compare the smaller upright view with what you saw on the inside. A spoon has its own curves and finish, so write down what this specimen showed. Exploratorium, the geometry of seeing.

If your unit has a small flat mirror, add a fifth row to the sheet. Put the arrow at the position used for one spoon observation and describe the image in the flat mirror. Your instructor can draw light paths afterward to help explain the views the unit recorded. Point to the particular observation that each drawing is meant to explain.

Read alsoAracaju’s Emare rowing project: how does an oar turn around a pivot?
Advertisementpreview

What to try when the image is difficult to recognize

Clean and dry the spoon. Adjust the angle slowly until you can see the arrow. If the finish is badly marked, try a second spoon and record that change in materials. Your face can be the object, but an arrow makes it easy to show which end was supposed to point up. Start with a large dark arrow on light paper if small details are difficult to distinguish.

When you find a change in orientation, keep the spoon still and repeat the paper movement twice. Record an interval of positions where you saw the change. Invite another pair to try the same setup with the same spoon. In your presentation, show the object, the side being viewed and the recorded distance. Another unit should be able to connect each description to a setup it can try for itself.

To check the sheet without using a face, draw two arrows, one pointing up and one sideways. Mark which tip appeared at the top of the image. A description such as “it looked different” can become “the upward arrow's tip appeared at the bottom.” Your partner now has a visible feature to look for. In a later round, keep the drawing and try a second spoon. The two records show exactly which object or utensil changed between the observations.

Further reading: Exploratorium, curved mirror comparison