For young people aged 10–15, the task is to compare structures in identified images. There is no need to approach a beach animal to inspect its head or provoke movement to check how it travels on land.
What a true seal means
NOAA Fisheries distinguishes phocids from otariids. True seals belong to the first group. They have ear openings but lack the small external ear flaps visible in the second group.
“Without external ear flaps” does not mean “deaf.” Keep that precise wording in your caption rather than turning a structural difference into a claim that the animal cannot hear.
Sea lions and fur seals belong together here
Otariids include sea lions and fur seals. They have small visible external ear flaps. A fur seal’s English name therefore does not make it a true seal in the phocid sense used by the comparison.
When sharing material across languages, retain the species’ scientific name or institutional identification beside the image. A common name may change by region, and a translation should not silently change the animal’s biological group.
Flippers add another useful observation
The Smithsonian compares seals and sea lions, including their structures and locomotion. Otariids can bring their rear flippers beneath the body to support movement on land.
True seals do not make that same movement. Participants do not need to imitate the animals with their own bodies. An institutional sequence or a diagram with arrows can show where the animal supports itself.
Read alsoIs every spiny succulent a cactus? Look for areolesPoint to the structure rather than only the answer
Choose an identified true seal image and an identified sea lion image. Draw an arrow to the ear opening or visible flap, depending on what the photograph shows. Next, mark the front flippers.
Redwood National and State Parks provides an illustrated comparison. Use it to check each arrow’s endpoint. An arrow near the head without reaching the relevant structure does not yet demonstrate recognition.
Add a third image
Include an identified fur seal from the references. Ask whether the word “seal” forces it into the true-seal group. The answer should rely on group membership and characteristics rather than the wording of its name alone.
Hide the captions while keeping the images in the same order. A partner explains the classification by pointing to visible evidence. Restore the names to check whether the reader recognized the group or merely memorized positions on the sheet.
A photograph can hide the necessary evidence
An animal photographed from behind or with its head submerged may hide the ear region. Write “not visible in this image.” Missing photographic detail does not establish that the animal lacks the structure.
The final worksheet can separate institutional identification, observed characteristic and missing information. It remains useful even when a photograph cannot answer every question.
Finish when the young reader can explain why a brown coat is insufficient and why a fur seal can share characteristics with sea lions. Explaining evidence is more useful than guessing a species from a distant image.
For revision, change the positions of all three photographs. If the classification changes although their visible structures remain the same, return to the arrows and references before calling the exercise complete.