This activity for ages 10 and above begins with photographs and definitions in the World Meteorological Organization's International Cloud Atlas. It does not require searching for the Sun with your eyes or pointing binoculars at it. Your product is an explanation preserving positional references rather than classifying by colour alone.
Zenith and horizon are different directions
The zenith is the direction directly above your head. The horizon is the apparent line separating sky and distant surface. Saying a band was “up there” may be insufficient to describe it.
A circumzenithal arc appears near the zenith. WMO describes bright colours with red on the lower outer edge and violet on the upper inner edge. It occurs when the light source, such as the Sun, is below 32 degrees of elevation.
Elevation means angle above the horizon: zero is towards the horizon, while 90 degrees is directly overhead. It is not the Sun's temperature or a measure of heat.
A second arc supports comparison
A circumhorizontal arc extends near and approximately parallel to the horizon. WMO states that it requires the light source to be above 58 degrees of elevation.
These are not two names for the same band. Position and the source's elevation are part of the distinction. Both can have vivid colours; choosing the most colourful photograph does not resolve identification.
Nor do the stated conditions guarantee seeing either phenomenon on an outing. Appropriate atmospheric conditions are also required.
Prepare contextual image reading
The instructor selects identified images from WMO references and keeps their names and origins available. View the original page rather than copying other people's photographs onto the club's website.
Before revealing the example's name, seek orientation information. Does the photograph show where the horizon is? Does its description explain that the camera pointed upwards? Context may appear in the caption rather than inside the frame.
A tightly cropped image may lack the information needed to locate the arc. State what you cannot conclude in that situation. A colourful crop does not identify its part of the sky by itself.
Read alsoKambuchi in Tobatí: Pathfinders try joining clay coils to a baseCompare location before appearance
For each example, first answer whether the reference indicates a region near the zenith or horizon. Only then describe shape and colours. This prevents treating “it looks like a smile” as a scientific definition.
One pair can present an example without naming it and ask another to locate evidence in the caption and atlas description. Then reveal the source's identification.
Do not turn this into a guessing contest. If orientation information is missing, the team can ask for the required detail.
Explain the difference with a spatial model
In a room, one participant points above their head and another indicates an imaginary horizontal line ahead. Use gestures and words to distinguish the references without representing the Sun with a bright lamp.
Then explain why “near the zenith” does not mean “around the Sun in any position”. Read the phenomenon's definition and relationship to the light source rather than deducing them from one isolated photograph.
The model helps explain position but does not produce a real halo. It is neither an ice-crystal formation experiment nor a measurement of WMO's angles.
Write a caption with appropriate certainty
A practice caption can say that the WMO-identified image shows a circumzenithal arc high in the sky. If the unit took its own photograph without enough information, describe it as an unidentified colourful arc.
Distinguish learning a reference example from identifying a new observation. This improves the club's weather record and avoids assigning a name simply because it matches a general appearance.
Finally, ask another pair to identify which orientation detail is missing from a cropped image. Recognizing a limitation is an evidence-based response even when it does not produce immediate identification.
For a clearer presentation, keep both phenomenon names beside their respective definitions until everyone finishes comparing. Removing labels too soon can turn a useful reference task into a spelling-memory test.